Choose the workflow that fits
ShyftPay vs
WageTally.
A paycheck difference is the start of a question. Choose how you want to find it, review it, and keep the details.
Competitor sources checked October 11, 2026 · ShyftPay details updated November 2, 2026
What each app brings.
WageTally’s website describes a local shift-pay tracker with expected gross totals, overtime, differentials and role premiums. Its App Store download button currently opens a listing named ShiftProof Pay Tracker, so these website claims should not be read as verified features of the listed app. Source: WageTally’s product and pricing page; linked App Store listing.
ShyftPay’s focus
Review the entered earnings, preserve the comparison, and turn an unexplained difference into a clear payroll inquiry.
We have reviewed published descriptions, not independently tested these competing apps.
| What matters | ShyftPay iPhone | WageTally |
|---|---|---|
| Paycheck comparison | Confirmed earnings lines compared with your entered shifts and pay rules. Photo/PDF suggestions always go through review. | Expected period gross is shown for comparison with your paycheck. |
| Saved evidence | Each comparison preserves the paystub, shifts and rules used. Later edits do not rewrite an earlier comparison. | Pay history and exports are advertised; immutable comparison-input handling is not specified. |
| Unknown earnings | Unclear or missing categories remain unknown. A zero requires explicit confirmation that the category was not paid. | Missing-versus-zero category handling is not specified. |
| Overtime | Base-only, differential-inclusive, or weighted workweek estimates. Weighted rates use one base rate plus selected premiums, with full-week review and saved calculation details. | Weekly thresholds, differentials and role premiums are advertised. |
| Devices and workplaces | One workplace per ledger, on iPhone. Encrypted manual backups; no calendar sync, iCloud sync or widgets in the iPhone app. | Free: one workplace. Pro: unlimited workplaces, templates, recurrence and a widget. |
| Pricing | Free tracking and one new paycheck comparison per device; rechecks of previously compared paychecks stay free. Plus: $4.99/month or $39.99/year (USD). | WageTally website: from $5.99/month or $39.99/year, with a seven-day trial advertised. Its App Store link opens ShiftProof Pay Tracker, which lists $5.99/month and $39.99/year; check the purchase sheet for any trial. |
| Payroll follow-up | Editable inquiry drafts tied to the saved comparison. PDF/CSV inquiry exports with Plus; full-ledger backups stay free. | PDF and CSV exports are advertised; inquiry drafting is not specified. |
Competitor column: WageTally’s product and pricing page and its linked ShiftProof App Store listing, checked October 11, 2026. The site and listing use different product names; features in the WageTally column are the site’s claims. “Not specified” means we could not establish that detail from this source; it does not mean the feature is absent. Pricing, availability, features and trials can change by region. ShyftPay’s prices are configured for its Plus subscription; final terms appear in Apple’s purchase sheet.
Choose for your routine.
Consider the workflow advertised on WageTally’s site if multiple workplaces, recurring shifts and a pay-period widget are priorities; confirm the current app identity and features before choosing.
Consider ShyftPay when you want a deliberate confirmation step, visible unknowns, a preserved comparison, and an editable inquiry you can review before sharing.
Compare the workflows.
Use the same shifts and paystub to evaluate a tool. Check the rules, the explanation of each difference, and what stays available if you stop subscribing.
Download on the App Store ↗Keep comparing
Product names belong to their respective owners. ShyftPay is not affiliated with or endorsed by these products.